Woot!! This was one annoying ass bug!!

Judgement bug fixed
Okay, we think we have been able to isolate this bug and put in a fix that prevents Judgements from failing any longer. Assuming a little more testing supports this conclusion we plan on hotfixing this.

Sorry you had to endure it for so long. (Source)

In case you didn’t know about the bug, here is what was happening. Sometimes, when casting judgement of *wisdom/light/justice*, the judgement would “fail”. By fail, I mean that no damage was caused to the mob and they would not receive the debuff but the CD on the spell would begin and the mana was consumed. If the pally was ret, the failed judgement meant that there was no mana returned (via Judgements of the Wise) and replenishment does not start ticking.

Hopefully, this bug is gone.